Before the Beginning

Comets As Probes of Pre-solar System History

When comets do a turn around the Sun, they leave behind streams of dust particles that Earth eventually intersects in its own orbit around the Sun. Most of the time we see these particles as they enter our atmosphere and burn up. It’s rare to get samples of these dusty bits, but when planetary scientists DO get them, they’ve basically gotten their hands on very old, very primitive bits of material that existed LONG before the Sun and planets did. This is because comets formed out of the materials in the protosolar nebula — essentially they’re orbiting deep-freezes of ice and dust.  Scientists have long known about comets and their treasure troves of ancient stuff.  In 2003, they managed to gather up good samples of Comet 26P/Grigg-Skjellerup and have been studying them since then.

Interplanetary dust particles showing pre-solar grains of silicates and organic matter that originated in interstellar space. Courtesy H. Busemann. Click to embiggenate.
Interplanetary dust particles showing pre-solar grains of silicates and organic matter that originated in interstellar space. Courtesy H. Busemann. (Click to embiggenate.)

The findings are amazing. According to Dr. Henner Busemann of the University of Manchester, who is presenting these results on Tuesday at the European Week of Astronomy and Space Science being held at University of Hertfordshire in the U.K., the dust grains have all the signs of being very ancient — predating the birth of the Sun and planets. Some of it is true stardust, floating in interstellar space after being ejected during the process of birth, life and death of other stars. “We found an extraordinary wealth of primitive chemical fingerprints,” he said, “including abundant pre-solar grains, true stardust that has formed around other earlier stars, some during supernova explosions, associated with extremely pristine organic matter that must pre-date the formation of our planets.”

You can see a sample of the dust particles here. They are extremely tiny — only a few thousands of a millimeter in diameter.   Two grains appear to have materials that scientists predict match the solar system’s birth nebula. One dust particle contained four pre-solar silicate grains (meaning grains that existed well before the solar system’s birth nebula formed) with an unusual chemical composition that matches the kinds of silicate grains that might form in supernova explosions. This is pretty good evidence that our birth nebula was seeded by the death throes of older, massive stars that once existed near our part of the galaxy.

More closeups of comet dust grains from the pre-solar-system neighborhood, more than 4.5 billion years ago. (Click to embiggenate.)
More closeups of comet dust grains from the pre-solar-system neighborhood, more than 4.5 billion years ago. (Click to embiggenate.)

One of these grains is a fragment of olivine and was found next to a hollow globule of carbon, most likely of interstellar origin. Carbon is an interesting element to find because it is intimately bound up in the structures that ultimately build life.

Organic coatings are suspected to be the shells of time capsules that protected and secured the survival of some of these fragile stellar silicate grains as they made their way through the interstellar environment and, later on, the high radiation environment of the newly forming Sun.

Detecting the Chemistry of Life

This isn’t the only big news coming from the WASS meeting.  Two researchers are also presenting a paper about the detection of two of the most complex molecules yet discovered in interstellar space: ethyl formate and n-propyl cyanide. Their computational models of interstellar chemistry also indicate that yet larger organic molecules may be present — including the so-far elusive amino acids, which are essential for life. The scientists used the IRAM 30-meter telescope in Spain to look at a region of the sky near the star-forming region Sagittarius B2.  The molecules were found in a hot, dense cloud of gas that also contains a newly formed star.

Large, organic molecules of many different sorts have been detected in this cloud in the past, including alcohols, aldehydes, and acids. The new molecules ethyl formate (C2H5OCHO) and n-propyl cyanide (C3H7CN) represent two different classes of molecule — esters and alkyl cyanides — and they are the most complex of their kind yet detected in interstellar space.

This is pretty cool news on both fronts. These findings by separate groups of scientists tell us that we (our planet and our star) came from some of the same processes we see happening throughout the galaxy.  The precursors of life are out there floating around in interstellar space, and scientists are finding more and more of them. It’s one thing to know and suspect these facts, but quite exciting to find evidence of our origins as part of the normal evolution of the universe and its stars and galaxies.

When I Met Stephen Hawking

in Utah

Dr. Stephen Hawking, courtesy Wikimedia Commons.
Dr. Stephen Hawking, courtesy Wikimedia Commons.

News today is that British scientist Stephen Hawking is very ill and is in the hospital. No word yet on how serious his condition is but we are hoping for the best for this man, who has accomplished so much despite so many obstacles posed by his motor neurone disease.

Some years ago Mark and I and our brother-in-law Tony had the chance to meet Dr. Hawking in Salt Lake City. He was there as part of a promotion for a film being made about his life and work, and some of the production team members invited us to come over for a special reception with Dr. Hawking and then hear him give a talk at the University of Utah arena.  It was probably one of the coolest and yet strangest experiences of our lives.

There are three things I’ve never forgotten about the visit.  The first was when we met him at the reception. He wheeled in and we all stared at each other in silent appreciation. Then, he activated his voice synthesizer and we all greeted each other.  I think most of us didn’t really know what to ask or say, but we all muddled through.  There was one moment when I felt we were all in some sort of surreal, subdued “exhibit” atmosphere, and I’ve often wondered who was more of an exhibit — us or Dr. Hawking.

The second moment was when Dr. Hawking gave his talk to a standing ovation crowd at the arena.  First they played his scene from Star Trek: The Next Generation episode “Descent.”  That brought the house down. Then, as that faded out, Dr. Hawking wheeled up onto the stage like a rock star.  The crowd went wild and from that moment on, he had them in the palm of his voice synthesizer. One of the people we were sitting with leaned over and said in wonderment, “It’s amazing to see this many people get together to hear a lecture on cosmology and astrophysics from a guy who can’t talk.”  It was amazing. And extremely gratifying.

The third moment came the next day when a small group of us accompanied Dr. Hawking out to Evans & Sutherland so that he could tour their flight simulators and planetarium installations.  The high point of that day was when they loaded him into a flight simulator, showed him how to fly it, and let him loose.  In one simulation he practiced shooting moving targets and when he hit one, he grinned like a kid in a candy shop and tapped out on his voice synthesizer, “I deaded it.”  (I’m guessing he didn’t have the word “killed” in the memory banks.)

I’ve had a lot of time to think about those three days in Salt Lake City and it has taken me a while to write about it. I had a request for a story about it at the time, and I couldn’t do it — it would have felt exploitative of a man who had no defenses against such stories.  Or maybe I didn’t feel I could do it justice. Maybe I still haven’t, but it feels like the right time to talk about it. In a strange sense, putting Stephen Hawking in a flight simulator is a completely natural thing to do, and I often have wondered if he would be the philosophical prototype of a research project where a perfectly functioning human brain is transplanted into the cyborg world of a simulator.  Clearly he will not be doing that completely — but watching him play and learn in that simulator, and watching him in subsequent experiences on a zero-gravity simulation flight, showed me that such human-machine mergings are in our future. And, more importantly, the human who does it won’t lose his or her humanity. Far from it. Stephen Hawking is a man tethered to a machine, and yet, he was having fun and that was what counted!  I hope he will be with us a while longer and continue having fun as he lives on.