Dumb Questions? NO.
I’ve been following the latest kerfuffle over a CNN anchor asking Bill Nye if a near-Earth asteroid swinging close to Earth had anything to do with global warming. In watching the video of the question, it’s pretty clear to me that the anchor doesn’t really think that climate change and the asteroid have anything to do with each other. She’s trying to make a transition from one story to the next in a crowded broadcast. But, it was a pretty clumsy segue. Nye’s response was a nice educational linkage between words that astronomers use (like meteors and meteorology, and so on). I thought he handled it pretty well.
A lot of commentators online have really come down on the anchor for asking what seemed like a dumb question. You know what? There’s no such thing as a dumb question. There are ill-thought-out questions. There are uninformed questions, and loaded ones and sarcastic ones, but they’re not dumb. This question led to a teachable moment in science for the anchor and presumably for the audience members watching the show. So, it’s all good. Maybe next time the anchor will think twice before asking once. And, maybe somebody in the audience learned something about how scientists should answer questions (even loaded, awkward ones).
There are a lot of really misguided things that people say, particularly when it comes to science. And, they deserve to get called out on whatever misunderstanding they have that led to the questions. They also deserve rational answers from scientists. I am not for one minute defending the creationist claims about biology or evolution. Those are indefensible because they come from a position of wilful ignorance (and sometimes wilful lying) by those who preach them. Nor am I defending the ideas espoused by the oil and gas companies that are paying scientists to denounce human involvement in global warming and pollution. Those come from people who have a stake in maintaining the status quo at the expense of the planet and have little to do with the actual science they are deriding.
I am saying, however, that learning involves asking questions. And, that’s why there’s no such thing as a dumb question. Good, honest attempts to find out about our planet, our life forms, the scientific discoveries that inform us about the cosmos are never dumb. And, for those of us who bring science to the public, there’s always a teachable moment ? even when a TV anchor asks an awkward question. I like how Bill Nye handled it. We should all be so quick to use our knowledge to teach.
Ok, perhaps not a dumb question but a ill-thought-out question, as you suggested. But the frequency of such ‘ill-thought-out’ questions on CNN after they sacked their Science and Space experts (remember Miles O’Brien, and others?) has become annoyingly large, unfortunately. CNN cannot be taken seriously anymore; they’re no longer showing news, they’re showing ‘infotainment’. It’s great that Bill Nye went on CNN to explain things, though!
There are plenty of us out here ready to explain scientific ideas in language non-scientists can understand. It’s my career, actually, both writing articles and producing videos about science. There are SO many things about the cosmos to share!